scoring question?

This message is not archived
 >> Stay informed about: scoring question? 

On Apr 22, 7:59 pm, "A" <a....TakeThisOut@att.net> wrote:
> x-no-archive: yes
>
> "HankC" <cla....TakeThisOut@missouri.edu> wrote in message
>
> news:98278df4-35ef-4a8c-90ac-20fe1bd3985b@x41g2000hsb.googlegroups.com...
>
> > runner on first, 2 outs,
>
> > the speedy batter laces one down the line, circles the bases and
> > slides safely into third.
>
> > a split second later, the slower base runner is thrown out at home for
> > the third out.
>
> > is this a triple or a double?
>
>                 It's a TRIPLE, since he slud into 3b!
>                 <G, I just love saying 'slud', a la Dizzy Dean>
>
>                 Also, score a FC (ex., 9-2 or 7-2) for the out by the slow
> runner at Home.

that's what I think. A friend says it is a double and advances to
third on the FC...timing has naught to do with it...


HankC
 >> Stay informed about: scoring question? 

On Tue, 22 Apr 2008 12:30:43 -0700 (PDT), HankC <clarkc.DeleteThis@missouri.edu>
wrote:

>runner on first, 2 outs,
>
>the speedy batter laces one down the line, circles the bases and
>slides safely into third.
>
>a split second later, the slower base runner is thrown out at home for
>the third out.
>
>is this a triple or a double?
>
>
>HankC

Double and advanced on a Fielders choice, I believe.

Here is a good one?

With one out the Slower runner gets tagged out at Home, but the batter
slides in right behind and scores, Inside the park HR or triple and
advanced on a Fielders Choice?
 >> Stay informed about: scoring question? 

HankC wrote:
> On Apr 22, 7:59 pm, "A" <a....TakeThisOut@att.net> wrote:
>> x-no-archive: yes
>>
>> "HankC" <cla....TakeThisOut@missouri.edu> wrote in message
>>
>> news:98278df4-35ef-4a8c-90ac-20fe1bd3985b@x41g2000hsb.googlegroups.com...
>>
>>> runner on first, 2 outs,
>>> the speedy batter laces one down the line, circles the bases and
>>> slides safely into third.
>>> a split second later, the slower base runner is thrown out at home for
>>> the third out.
>>> is this a triple or a double?
>> It's a TRIPLE, since he slud into 3b!
>> <G, I just love saying 'slud', a la Dizzy Dean>
>>
>> Also, score a FC (ex., 9-2 or 7-2) for the out by the slow
>> runner at Home.
>
> that's what I think. A friend says it is a double and advances to
> third on the FC...timing has naught to do with it...
>
>
> HankC

I am an umpire and here is a little known ruling:

Let's say there's a runner at 1st.

The batter hits the ball into the corner for extra bases. The runner
from first attempts to score but is going to be thrown out by such a
huge margin he attempts to abort his advance to home and gets caught in
a rundown between 3rd and home. Meanwhile, the batter pulls into 3rd
while the rundown is still going on. The runner who is trapped in the
rundown commits an interference violation (i.e. intentionally
bumps/touches a fielder or intentionally tries to get struck by the
ball). The play immediately becomes dead. The runner who is guilty of
the interference is out, and the runner standing on 3rd must return to 2nd.

The other runner has to return since, on interference, all other runners
must return to the last base "legally touched" at the time of the
interference. At the time of the interference, 3rd base was "owned" by
the trapped runner.

Although, I don't think that rule interpretation would have any effect
on the scoring as stated in the original post.

I'd rule it a triple, also.

David Emerling
Memphis, TN
 >> Stay informed about: scoring question? 

This message is not archived
 >> Stay informed about: scoring question? 

On Apr 27, 12:06 am, "A" <a....TakeThisOut@att.net> wrote:
> x-no-archive: yes
>
> "David Emerling" <davidemerlingDEL....TakeThisOut@gmail.com> wrote in message
>
> news:s5Sdna8Gpdcx347VnZ2dnUVZ_oaonZ2d@comcast.com...
>
>
>
>
>
> > HankC wrote:
> >> On Apr 22, 7:59 pm, "A" <a....TakeThisOut@att.net> wrote:
> >>> x-no-archive: yes
>
> >>> "HankC" <cla....TakeThisOut@missouri.edu> wrote in message
>
> >>>news:98278df4-35ef-4a8c-90ac-20fe1bd3985b@x41g2000hsb.googlegroups.com....
>
> >>>> runner on first, 2 outs,
> >>>> the speedy batter laces one down the line, circles the bases and
> >>>> slides safely into third.
> >>>> a split second later, the slower base runner is thrown out at home for
> >>>> the third out.
> >>>> is this a triple or a double?
> >>>                 It's a TRIPLE, since he slud into 3b!
> >>>                 <G, I just love saying 'slud', a la Dizzy Dean>
>
> >>>                 Also, score a FC (ex., 9-2 or 7-2) for the out by the
> >>> slow
> >>> runner at Home.
>
> >> that's what I think. A friend says it is a double and advances to
> >> third on the FC...timing has naught to do with it...
>
> >> HankC
>
> > I am an umpire and here is a little known ruling:
>
> > Let's say there's a runner at 1st.
>
> > The batter hits the ball into the corner for extra bases. The runner from
> > first attempts to score but is going to be thrown out by such a huge
> > margin he attempts to abort his advance to home and gets caught in a
> > rundown between 3rd and home. Meanwhile, the batter pulls into 3rd while
> > the rundown is still going on. The runner who is trapped in the rundown
> > commits an interference violation (i.e. intentionally bumps/touches a
> > fielder or intentionally tries to get struck by the ball). The play
> > immediately becomes dead. The runner who is guilty of the interference is
> > out, and the runner standing on 3rd must return to 2nd.
>
> > The other runner has to return since, on interference, all other runners
> > must return to the last base "legally touched" at the time of the
> > interference. At the time of the interference, 3rd base was "owned" by the
> > trapped runner.
>
> > Although, I don't think that rule interpretation would have any effect on
> > the scoring as stated in the original post.
>
> > I'd rule it a triple, also.
>
> > David Emerling
> > Memphis, TN
>
>             Isn't there something in the rule book about the batter being
> more than halfway toward the next base when the runner is thrown out, he
> usually gets credit from the scorer (his judgment) for that next base; and
> therefore a
> TRIPLE is the correct ruling, as you mentioned?- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

In the famous case of Babe Herman 'doubling into a double play', the
lead runner was awarded third base, hence Herman and the sandwiched
runner were both declared out...

Not sure how that relates to this situation, but surely it must


HankC
 >> Stay informed about: scoring question?