On Wed, 8 Dec 2004 01:29:35 -0500, "David Szabo"
<dave.szabo.DeleteThis@sympatico.ca> wrote:
>Better lives?? How on earth can anyone think that life in Toronto is better
>than here, besides the language laws which since have been significantly
>relaxed. The cost of living in Toronto is significantly higher and the
>cultural scene there is pretty lacking. No one I know who moved to Toronto
>ended up any better off than they would have been here and many actually
>moved back to Montreal after a frustrated realization of this.
I was in Montreal last weekend and found the city to be dirty and
dull. Like many others, Montrealers like to think that their city stil
has the aura and mystiqwue that it did in the 50's and 60's. Those
days are long gone.
Yes, the cost of living is marginally higher than in Montreal, but the
incomes are significantly higher and ALL taxes are lower. My sister,
who lives in Montreal pays approximately $10k/yr. in property taxes. I
pay 1/3 of that amount in Toronto for a home that is worth quite a lot
more than my sister's. Income taxes are lower here and believe it or
not, the cost of consumer goods is generally lower here as well. I had
a copy of a Future Shop flyer which I brought with me to Montreal, as
my sister was looking to buy some video equipment. The Gazette had the
identical flyer with higher prices for the Future Shop stores in
Quebec! The difference was not significant, maybe $1-2 on a $100 item,
but the prices were higher in Montreal.
My hubby's income increased by over 30% for the identical work, when
he moved to Toronto. When factoring in the lower income and property
taxes, he ended up with appropximately 40% more cash in his pocket.
Cultural scene lacking? What a joke! With 4 theatres running
Broadway-level shows and many international acts playing Toronto
exclusively as their Canadian stops, the cultural scene is far more
vibrant here than in Montreal. How many Broadway/London shows does
Place des Arts host per year? One......two....?
Montrealers still think that its city has the best restaurants? Check
out the Zagat and Frohmer guides and see how many Montreal restaurants
are listed.
Sports? Well that's a joke too. Nordiques, Expos, Alouettes (once or
twice?) Concordes........
Toronto has a MLB team, an NBA team and contrary to Montrealer's
beliefs, if the NFL was to come to Canada, I think we all know which
city would get the franchise.
For 30 straight years, the exodus from Montreal to Toronto has
greartly exceeded the reverse. Montreal has higher poverty rates,
higher unemployment rates, lower immigration rates, lower GNP, lower
average incomes and far less multiculturalism (Toronto is the most
multiculturally diverse city in North America).
The only argument Montrealers tend to have these days is that Montreal
"has a better night life". Firstly, I've been hearing that since the
60's and it's cliched by now and BS. Secondly, how does one measure
the quality of a city's night life? You can't. And to be quite honest,
in the grand scheme of things for over-25's, it's really not that
important. Jobs, homes, schooling are the important issues in life not
whether a city's bars are open until 1:00, 2:00 or 3:00AM.
Language laws relaxed? They're racist! I continue to be disgusted by
indoor signs in Quebec that have their English descriptions at half
the size of the French equivalent....and it's the law! There are
stores in Toronto that have signs exclusively in Chines, Phillipino,
Arabic, etc. Freedom of expression is the law in North
America.....excpet for Quebec, of course.
If I move to Quebec from Spain with my wife and two 5 year olds, I am
forced by law to enrol the kids in a French school, even if they speak
English perfectly and not a single word of French! Racist!
If I want my communications with the government in English, I have to
request it in writing. The fact that documents can be printed in
English on one side and in French on the other is irrelevent to the
Quebec politicians. French it is.
In 1993, the United Nations Human Rights Committee ruled that Quebec's
sign laws broke an international covenant on civil and political
rights. "A State may choose one or more official languages, the
committee wrote, but it may not exclude outside the spheres of public
life, the freedom to express oneself in a certain language.
Reacting to these events, Robert Bourassa introduced Bill 86, which
allowed English on outdoor commercial signs only if the French
lettering was at least twice as large as the English.
The fact that Quebec has been admonished by the United Nations should
have made the feds in Ottawa cut off all payments to Quebec until
these laws were reversed. But they're afraid of losing Quebec
federalist voters.
So, to be honest, I can't think of one good reason for a
non-Francophone to live in Montreal. Sure, if someone has lived there
all of his/her life and doesn't want to make a move, then by all means
enjoy all that Montreal has to offer. but, in terms of economic,
cultural and social benefits, there ain't no comparison.
Having lived in Montreal for more than 1/2 of my life, I think I have
a good perspective on the merits of the two cities.
Roberta
Whew....that was long one.
>> Stay informed about: How did population decline affect Expos attendance?