WJ's first report card

On Aug 1, 10:50 am, t... DeleteThis @nomail.please (JustTom) wrote:
> On Fri, 1 Aug 2008 11:07:06 -0400, "Bob Braun"
>
>
>
> <oxin... DeleteThis @hotandsunnymail.com> wrote:
>
> >"JustTom" <t... DeleteThis @nomail.please> wrote in message
> >news:48930a4a.668981596@newsgroups.comcast.net...
> >> Gets an F from me.
>
> >> I believe we had more FA's this year than in most recent years, and
> >> yet he did nothing.
>
> >> I'm kind of stunned that Affeldt, Fogg, and Weathers are still here,
> >> and disappointed that Ross is as well.
>
> >> And before anybody gives him credit for KGJ, all reports I've seen are
> >> that Kenny Williams called Walt out of the blue on Wednesday, and WJ
> >> was stunned when he asked about KGJ.   Williams has had a hankering
> >> for him for several years.
>
> >> Am I being unfair?
>
> >Yes, you are being unfair.  We don't want Jocketty going knee-jerk.
> >Preliminary chatter was that Krivsky left the cupboard more full than did
> >O'Brien.  Full of what?
>
> I don't see how Fogg, Affeldt, Weathers, and Ross count as emptying
> the cupboard or qualify as "knee-jerk".   They are the type of
> veterans in the last year of a deal that you are supposed to flip for
> whatever you can get out of them.
>
> Most likely, they aren't coming back,  aren't wanted back, and won't
> net any picks when they do leave ecause we won't want to offer
> arbitration.

But what do you think you're going to get in return for those guys?
Junior was traded to a team that really wanted him, and all that got
the Reds was a pair of insignificant prospects, neither of whom are
projected to make it in the majors. Here's a better question: if you
had a major league team in a pennant race, would you give up a good
minor leaguer to add Josh Fogg's 7.84 ERA or David Ross's .244 batting
average?

I could see possibly flipping the relievers, but consider the braves
couldn't even move Will Ohman, there wasn't much market for those
kinds of guys this year.
 >> Stay informed about: WJ's first report card 

On Fri, 1 Aug 2008 11:07:06 -0400, "Bob Braun"
<oxinfla.RemoveThis@hotandsunnymail.com> wrote:

>
>"JustTom" <tom.RemoveThis@nomail.please> wrote in message
>news:48930a4a.668981596@newsgroups.comcast.net...
>> Gets an F from me.
>>
>> I believe we had more FA's this year than in most recent years, and
>> yet he did nothing.
>>
>> I'm kind of stunned that Affeldt, Fogg, and Weathers are still here,
>> and disappointed that Ross is as well.
>>
>> And before anybody gives him credit for KGJ, all reports I've seen are
>> that Kenny Williams called Walt out of the blue on Wednesday, and WJ
>> was stunned when he asked about KGJ. Williams has had a hankering
>> for him for several years.
>>
>> Am I being unfair?
>
>Yes, you are being unfair. We don't want Jocketty going knee-jerk.
>Preliminary chatter was that Krivsky left the cupboard more full than did
>O'Brien. Full of what?

I don't see how Fogg, Affeldt, Weathers, and Ross count as emptying
the cupboard or qualify as "knee-jerk". They are the type of
veterans in the last year of a deal that you are supposed to flip for
whatever you can get out of them.

Most likely, they aren't coming back, aren't wanted back, and won't
net any picks when they do leave ecause we won't want to offer
arbitration.
 >> Stay informed about: WJ's first report card 

"JustTom" <tom.RemoveThis@nomail.please> wrote in message
news:4893219c.674951921@newsgroups.comcast.net...
> On Fri, 1 Aug 2008 11:07:06 -0400, "Bob Braun"
> <oxinfla.RemoveThis@hotandsunnymail.com> wrote:
>
>>
>>"JustTom" <tom.RemoveThis@nomail.please> wrote in message
>>news:48930a4a.668981596@newsgroups.comcast.net...
>>> Gets an F from me.
>>>
>>> I believe we had more FA's this year than in most recent years, and
>>> yet he did nothing.
>>>
>>> I'm kind of stunned that Affeldt, Fogg, and Weathers are still here,
>>> and disappointed that Ross is as well.
>>>
>>> And before anybody gives him credit for KGJ, all reports I've seen are
>>> that Kenny Williams called Walt out of the blue on Wednesday, and WJ
>>> was stunned when he asked about KGJ. Williams has had a hankering
>>> for him for several years.
>>>
>>> Am I being unfair?
>>
>>Yes, you are being unfair. We don't want Jocketty going knee-jerk.
>>Preliminary chatter was that Krivsky left the cupboard more full than did
>>O'Brien. Full of what?
>
> I don't see how Fogg, Affeldt, Weathers, and Ross count as emptying
> the cupboard or qualify as "knee-jerk". They are the type of
> veterans in the last year of a deal that you are supposed to flip for
> whatever you can get out of them.
>
> Most likely, they aren't coming back, aren't wanted back, and won't
> net any picks when they do leave ecause we won't want to offer
> arbitration.

I guess it just depends if you can get anything at all in return. I don't
them see getting much. There's really no urgency to part with them.
 >> Stay informed about: WJ's first report card