David Ortiz for Albert Pujols trade

Is this a rediculously unfair trade?

There is a trade pending in our league and the commissioner wrote:

"I am strongly considering disallowing this trade. If there is a
majority of the rest that think this is actually fair I'll let it
through. But I honestly think this is quite possibly the worst serious
trade I've ever seen proposed."

Your opinions???

If they want to trade, let them trade on this one. The Cards certainly
aren't even as mediocre good as last year meaning less run/rbi chances for
Pujols. Witness his worst April ever. I don't think the difference between
the 2 are as lopsided this year than before. Looking at last year's stats,
they are even in runs and rbis, while Ortiz got you 5 more homers and Pujols
another 5 steals and 35 avg points (ok well this is alot). If you block this
trade, then you start down a slippery slope as to what's blockable. What if
you want to trade Mo Rivera for Joe Nathan? And if this is the worst trade
he's seen, then he hasn't played long enough.


--


Tony Shek
http://www.myspace.com/tonyshek
http://blog.myspace.com/tonyshek


<infinitisound DeleteThis @yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1178434391.409942.31810@u30g2000hsc.googlegroups.com...
> Is this a rediculously unfair trade?
>
> There is a trade pending in our league and the commissioner wrote:
>
> "I am strongly considering disallowing this trade. If there is a
> majority of the rest that think this is actually fair I'll let it
> through. But I honestly think this is quite possibly the worst serious
> trade I've ever seen proposed."
>
> Your opinions???
>